Branded Mini-Games Get 6x More Redemptions Than Email Reminders

A customer has 5,000 unredeemed loyalty points. You send an email: "You have rewards waiting! Click here to redeem."

Open rate: 15%. Click rate: 3%. Redemption rate: 1%.

Now imagine the same customer receives an invitation to play a 30-second game where they can win bonus points and redeem their existing balance through interactive gameplay.

Engagement rate: 40%. Completion rate: 85%. Redemption rate: 37%.

The difference isn't the reward. It's the delivery mechanism. Games transform passive point balances into active engagement.

Why Games Change Redemption Behavior

The psychology of gameplay creates conditions that overcome typical redemption barriers:

Active Over Passive

Email requests passive response. Open, read, click, decide, redeem. Each step creates dropout.

Games request active participation. Play creates momentum that carries through to redemption. You're already engaged; redemption is the natural conclusion.

Variable Rewards Built In

Traditional redemption is fixed: X points for Y reward. Games introduce variability: spin results, bonus chances, surprise outcomes.

This variability activates dopamine systems that fixed redemption cannot. The excitement of uncertain outcomes motivates engagement.

Time Compression

Email invites procrastination. "I'll redeem later" is easy when there's no urgency.

Games create immediate engagement. You're playing now, deciding now, redeeming now. The compressed timeframe prevents the deferral that kills redemption rates.

Decision Simplification

Games can present redemption choices as game outcomes rather than conscious decisions:

• "You won: Free coffee or 500 bonus points?"
• "Your prize: Choose your reward!"

The game context simplifies what would otherwise feel like complex redemption decisions.

Positive Emotional State

Gameplay puts customers in positive emotional states. Happy customers are more likely to take action than neutral or hesitant customers.

The enjoyment of the game transfers to the redemption decision, making spending points feel like winning rather than losing.

Types of Reward-Delivery Games

Several game formats work effectively for reward delivery:

Spin-to-Win Wheels

Classic wheel mechanics work because they're universally understood and create anticipation during the spin.

Implementation for rewards:

• Wheel sections display different redemption options
• Guaranteed wins (every spin redeems something)
• Bonus sections for surprise additional rewards
• Visual celebration when the wheel stops

The spinning animation creates anticipation that email links cannot match.

Scratch Cards

Digital scratch-to-reveal mechanics create physical engagement (even via touchscreen) and discovery excitement.

Implementation for rewards:

• Hidden rewards revealed through scratching
• Multiple items to reveal (increasing engagement)
• Progressive reveals (scratch to see if you won more)
• Shareable results

Pick-a-Prize Games

Let customers choose among concealed options, combining decision-making with uncertainty.

Implementation for rewards:

• Three doors, boxes, or cards to choose from
• Different rewards behind each
• Optional "switch" mechanics that increase engagement
• Reveal of what they didn't choose (creating narrative)

Achievement Unlock

Present redemption as achievement earned through gameplay:

• Complete challenges to unlock rewards
• Progress bars showing approach to unlock
• Celebration animation when threshold reached

Points-as-Currency Games

Use accumulated points as in-game currency:

• Auction-style bidding for limited rewards
• Trading games where points transform into items
• Building games where points construct rewards

Case Studies in Gamified Redemption

Several brands have documented success with gamified reward delivery:

Retail Loyalty Games

A major retailer replaced standard reward emails with scratch card games. Results:

• Email open rates: 15% → 43%
• Redemption rates: 8% → 34%
• Customer satisfaction with program: +27%
• Cost per redemption: Reduced 45%

The game didn't change the rewards; it changed how rewards were delivered.

Restaurant Reward Games

A restaurant chain introduced spin-to-win for loyalty reward selection. Members spun to determine which reward they'd receive from their accumulated points.

Results:

• Redemption frequency increased 3x
• Visit frequency increased during promotional period
• Social media mentions of the game created organic marketing
• Customer feedback highlighted "fun" as key satisfaction driver

Travel Loyalty Games

An airline allowed members to play a brief game before selecting award redemptions. The game determined bonus miles added to whatever redemption they chose.

Results:

• Time spent in redemption flow increased (positive engagement)
• Completion rate improved despite longer flow
• Member satisfaction with redemption experience increased
• Repeat redemption rates improved

Implementing Reward Games

Successful gamified redemption requires thoughtful implementation:

Keep Games Brief

Reward games should take 30-60 seconds maximum. Longer games create dropout before redemption occurs.

The goal is engagement enhancement, not entertainment. Quick games add excitement without creating barrier.

Guarantee Positive Outcomes

Every game play should result in something positive. "You didn't win" after participating creates negative association with redemption.

Even "consolation prizes" should feel valuable:

• Minimum reward guaranteed
• Bonus chances on next play
• Entry into larger drawings

Make Rules Clear

Players should understand immediately what they can win and how. Confusion creates abandonment.

Simple mechanics (spin, scratch, pick) work better than complex games requiring explanation.

Celebrate Results

The reveal moment should feel celebratory:

• Animation and sound (optional, controllable)
• Clear display of what was won
• Comparison to other outcomes (you got the good one!)
• Easy sharing of results

Connect to Brand

Games should feel on-brand rather than generic. Visual design, reward types, and mechanics should align with brand personality.

A luxury brand needs elegant game design. A fun brand can be playful. Mismatch creates disconnection.

Integrate Smoothly

Games should integrate into existing redemption flows rather than replacing them entirely:

• Optional game layer (customers who want simple redemption can skip)
• Game as enhancement, not requirement
• Same rewards available through traditional redemption

Measure Carefully

Track game impact on:

• Redemption rates (primary goal)
• Time to redemption (should decrease)
• Customer satisfaction
• Repeat engagement
• Share/viral metrics

The Psychology Behind Game Effectiveness

Several psychological principles explain why games work:

The Peak-End Rule

People remember experiences based on emotional peaks and endings. Games create peaks (excitement of outcome) and positive endings (winning something).

Standard redemption has no peak and forgettable endings. Games create memorable experiences.

Completion Tendency

Once started, people want to complete games. This tendency carries them through to redemption.

Email doesn't trigger completion tendency. It's not a started task; it's an optional action.

Choice Architecture

Games provide choice architecture that guides toward redemption. The game presents options, creates momentum, and leads to action.

Email leaves all architecture to the customer. They must create their own path to redemption.

Social Proof Through Play

When games show how many others have played or what others have won, social proof encourages participation.

"10,000 rewards won today!" creates different psychology than "You have points to redeem."

Effort Justification

Having played a game, customers feel their effort deserves reward. This effort justification increases redemption likelihood.

Email requires no effort, so there's no investment driving completion.

Potential Pitfalls

Gamified redemption isn't without risks:

Game Fatigue

Customers can tire of games if overused. Reserve game mechanics for significant redemption opportunities rather than every interaction.

Perceived Manipulation

If games feel manipulative (false urgency, unfair odds), customer trust suffers. Ensure games are genuinely entertaining, not just engagement tricks.

Technical Failures

Games that load slowly, don't work on all devices, or glitch during play create worse experience than simple redemption.

Test thoroughly across devices and connections.

Privacy Concerns

Some customers find gamification invasive or annoying. Provide opt-out for those who prefer traditional redemption.

Regulatory Considerations

Games involving chance may face regulatory scrutiny in some jurisdictions. Ensure compliance with gambling and promotion laws.

Integration with Broader Loyalty Strategy

Gamified redemption should complement, not replace, broader loyalty strategy:

For High-Value Rewards

Save games for significant redemption moments. Everyday small redemptions may not warrant game overhead.

For Re-engagement

Games work well for re-engaging dormant members. The novelty of gameplay can reactivate accounts that ignore standard communications.

For Seasonal Campaigns

Limited-time game mechanics create urgency and excitement for seasonal promotions.

For Program Launches

Launching new loyalty features with games creates engagement and education simultaneously.

Application to Events

Event reward programs can leverage game mechanics:

Session Selection Games

Instead of browsing sessions, play a brief game that suggests sessions based on preferences and adds bonus content for participation.

Networking Games

Gamify networking rewards: earn points through connections, redeem through games that create unexpected introductions or access.

Badge and Achievement Reveals

Rather than simply awarding badges, create reveal moments with game mechanics that celebrate achievement.

Prize Drawings Enhancement

Transform passive prize drawing entry into active game participation that increases engagement with the drawing itself.

Sponsor Engagement Games

Sponsors can deliver rewards through branded games that create engagement while distributing value.

---

Email tells customers they have something. Games make customers feel they've won something. The difference in framing transforms passive point balances into active experiences. When redemption feels like winning rather than spending, customers engage more frequently and more positively. The reward itself hasn't changed. The experience of receiving it has.